Availability is a fundamental principle of cybersecurity, ensuring that authorized users have timely and reliable access to information and systems. However, not every instance of downtime or loss of availability qualifies as a security incident. Organizations must assess the nature and cause of each outage to determine its classification.
Distinguishing Between Technical Failures and Security Incidents
A loss of availability can stem from various factors, broadly categorized into:
-
Technical Failures: These include hardware malfunctions, software bugs, power outages, or misconfigurations. Such issues, while disruptive, are typically not considered security incidents unless they result from or expose security vulnerabilities.
-
Security Incidents: These involve deliberate actions by malicious actors aiming to disrupt services, such as Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks, ransomware infections, or unauthorized system intrusions.
For instance, the 2021 Colonial Pipeline ransomware attack led to a significant operational halt, exemplifying a loss of availability due to a security breach.
Evaluating an Outage
To determine whether a downtime event is a security incident, organizations should:
-
Investigate the Root Cause: Analyze system logs, error messages, and recent changes to identify whether the outage resulted from a technical issue or malicious activity.
-
Monitor for Indicators of Compromise (IoCs): Look for signs such as unusual network traffic, unauthorized access attempts, or anomalies that may suggest a cyber attack.
-
Assess Impact and Scope: Evaluate which systems and data are affected to understand the potential implications and whether sensitive information is at risk.
Defining Security Incidents
It's essential for organizations to establish clear criteria for what constitutes a security incident. According to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), a security incident involves a violation or imminent threat of violation of computer security policies, acceptable use policies, or standard security practices.
By implementing comprehensive monitoring, incident response plans, and regular system audits, organizations can effectively differentiate between technical failures and security breaches, ensuring appropriate responses to maintain system integrity and availability.
